Mathematician Claims AI Helped Solve Riemann Hypothesis
A mathematician claims to have solved the Riemann Hypothesis with the help of an AI assistant, though the proof has not been independently verified or peer-reviewed.
Claim of Solving the Riemann Hypothesis with Claude
Anthropic mathematician Levent Alpöge claims to have solved the Riemann Hypothesis, one of mathematics’ most notoriously difficult problems, with the help of Claude, according to a statement on his website. Alpöge asserts that Claude was integral to developing the proof, stating, 'I believe I have, working with Claude, discovered a proof of the Riemann Hypothesis.'Alpöge further notes that the method used in the proof extends beyond the Riemann Hypothesis, resolving the Generalized Riemann Hypothesis and potentially the Extended Riemann Hypothesis with additional time. The claim has sparked significant interest and debate within the mathematical community, though no independent verification or peer review of the proof has been reported.
Anthropic's Involvement and Response
Anthropic has not officially commented on the claim by mathematician Alex Alpöge that he solved a Millennium Prize problem using Claude, the company’s AI assistant. According to Alpöge’s website, he texted Anthropic CEO Dario Amodei about the solution late Sunday night and suggested delaying publication until after the company’s IPO on Thursday. However, Anthropic has not confirmed or denied any involvement in the research or the solution itself. The Verge reached out to Anthropic for comment but did not immediately hear back. Alpöge’s claim remains unverified by the mathematical community, and no official statement from Anthropic has been released regarding the matter. The company’s response, if any, is still pending.
Millennium Prize Problem Context and Requirements
The Millennium Prize problems represent some of the most challenging unsolved questions in mathematics, with the Riemann hypothesis being one of the seven original problems identified by the Clay Mathematics Institute. According to the institute’s rules, any proposed solution must be published and undergo at least two years of rigorous scrutiny before it can be considered for the prize, during which time it must gain “general acceptance in the global mathematics community.” Since the prize was established in 2000, only one problem—the Poincaré conjecture—has been officially solved. More recently, in September, OpenAI claimed to have made progress on the Navier-Stokes problem, which concerns the behavior of fluid flow. However, such claims remain subject to the same rigorous verification process required for all Millennium Prize problems.
Collaboration with Tristan Buckmaster and Previous Claims
Anthropic mathematician Alex Alpöge has collaborated with New York University mathematics professor Tristan Buckmaster on the Millennium Prize problem, according to The Verge AI. Buckmaster claimed in The Verge AI that OpenAI had produced a solution for Navier-Stokes using the same approach that Alpöge and he were exploring with OpenAI’s Codex and Claude. In July, Alpöge stated in The Verge AI that he solved the Jacobean conjecture using Claude, though this claim has not been independently verified. These developments highlight the growing role of AI in mathematical research, but they also raise questions about the verification process and the extent to which AI-assisted solutions can be considered fully human achievements. Buckmaster’s statements suggest that AI tools may be accelerating progress in complex mathematical problems, but the field remains cautious about attributing breakthroughs without rigorous peer review.
Controversies and Scrutiny Surrounding AI-Driven Mathematical Claims
Controversies and scrutiny have surrounded the claim by an Anthropic mathematician that an AI system named Claude solved a prestigious Millennium Prize problem. While the achievement has sparked interest, it has also raised concerns about the research practices involved. According to reports, the claim has been marred by allegations that it used unpublished work from mathematicians who had shared their research with its AI tools. In August, Anthropic stated it was working on the Riemann Hypothesis with Claude but emphasized that the techniques used by Claude were not expected to lead to a proof of the hypothesis. The solution, presented in Lean and published on the mathematician’s website, has not yet been accepted by the Clay Mathematics Institute, which oversees the Millennium Prize and offers a $1 million reward for each problem solved.
Sources and reporting notes
Based on published source material. No independent hands-on testing is claimed.