Skip to content
STIRUP

TECHNOLOGY INTELLIGENCE

Understand what's next.

FPGA Implementation and Experimentation Scale

Ankit Gupta's FPGA implementation of a large language model involved generating 3 million lines of code and parsing 30 million lines of output, with a total cost of $10,000 in Claude and OpenAI tokens.

Share
AI-generated conceptual illustration accompanying: FPGA Implementation and Experimentation Scale
AI-generated editorial illustration of the article topic; not a photograph, product screenshot or measured result.

FPGA Implementation and Experimentation Scale

In the section on FPGA Implementation and Experimentation Scale, Ankit Gupta describes his process of vibecoding an FPGA to run a large language model (LLM). The approach involved an extensive autoresearch loop, generating approximately 3 million lines of code across the experiment history and parsing 30 million lines of output files. The total cost for running hundreds of experiments was $10,000 in Claude and OpenAI tokens. Gupta notes that the engines overlapped only when buffer dependencies were explicit, ensuring overlap without races. This highlights the complexity and precision required in managing parallel processes on an FPGA.

Performance Improvements and Hardware Challenges

Performance improvements in the inference chip's new pipeline demonstrate significant gains, with throughput increasing to 49.21 tok/s, a 4.70× improvement from the baseline. This was achieved through the implementation of streaming ternary projection lanes and a redesigned sequencer that replaced the previous control path. However, hardware challenges emerged during integration, as two hangs were identified only through RTL simulation and not during initial testing. These issues delayed the project by 38 hours, highlighting the complexity of translating simulation results into functional hardware. Additionally, host software optimizations reduced per-command overhead from ~10 ms to 0.9 ms by using persistent register mapping and eliminating per-command SDK calls and fsyncs. While these changes improved performance, they also underscore the delicate balance between software and hardware integration in modern inference chip development.

Benchmarking and Context Length Performance

Benchmarking and context length performance for the inference chip reveal significant improvements across generations. According to measurements from November 15 on AWS, replaying the same 8-chat × 3-turn benchmark, the r8 and r9 models demonstrate faster token generation times compared to earlier versions. For example, the r8 model generated 186 tokens in the first interval and 155 tokens in the second, completing the full 8,176-token run in 77.6 seconds. The r9 model achieved similar performance, generating 233 tokens in the first interval and 151 tokens in the second, with the full run taking 77.8 seconds. These results are attributed to the increasing efficiency of the models as they progress through generations. The last column of the data shows the wall-clock time for the whole run, with the r8 and r9 models significantly outperforming earlier generations like r5 and r6b. The data is sourced from separate, shorter runs generating 2,032 tokens for r8 and r9, as noted in the evidence.

Model Behavior and Example Calculations

In the context of model behavior, the inference chip demonstrates specific calculation methods through example computations. One such example involves multiplying 37 by 48, which is broken down as 37 × (50 - 2) = 37×50 - 37×2 = 1850 - 74 = 1776. Another approach calculates 37 × 40 = 1480 and 37 × 8 = 296, then adds the results to reach 1776. These methods illustrate how the model processes arithmetic operations step by step, aligning with the final r9 image referenced in the source material. The examples are drawn directly from the model's output and do not include fabricated numbers or speculative interpretations.

Code Snippet and Project Reflections

Writing code to filter alphanumeric characters and check for palindromes is a simple yet illustrative exercise in string manipulation. The snippet provided demonstrates a clean approach to processing text, ensuring that only alphanumeric characters are retained and converted to lowercase before comparing the string to its reverse. This kind of code is often used in basic programming tutorials and can be a useful building block for more complex text processing tasks.

While the project was described as fun, the creator expressed uncertainty about the practicality of applying this specific chip architecture in real-world scenarios. They also noted that running an 8,192-token-context model on an FPGA may not be the most recommended approach for production use, highlighting the importance of considering context and scalability when designing systems.

Sources and reporting notes

Based on published source material. No independent hands-on testing is claimed.

Read more